"I cannot resist you": Love, Heart and Treasure in "Nosferatu" (2024)
In his classic “Anna Karenina” (1878), Russian author Leo Tolstoy wrote: "if it is true that there are as many minds as there are heads, then there are as many kinds of love as there are hearts.” In “Nosferatu” (2024), “love” and “heart” also take the central stage throughout the narrative. The Victorian characters couples address each other constantly by “my love” or “my lovely”, and there's no shortage of "I love you"; “love” in this story is connected with Victorian society, and the melodrama motif at play here. And Count Orlok "cannot love" in the present, within Victorian society nor its standards (in a reference to the "Dracula" novel by Bram Stoker: "Yes, I too can love. You yourselves can tell it from the past. Is it not so?”, here transformed in the reincarnation theme of "Remember how once we were? A moment. Remember?”).
Love and heart eventually become synonyms in the narrative, and this becomes apparent with the Solomonari instructions of the "breaking of Nosferatu curse": "And so the maiden fair did offer up her love unto the beast, and with him lay, in close embrace until the first cock crow. Her willing sacrifice thus broke the curse, and freed them from the plague of Nosferatu." Count Orlok feeds on the heart blood of the living, and as such the literal interpretation of "offer up her love" is "offer up her heart" for him to kill. "Offer up" is also connected with "offerings" in religious context, offer prayer or offer sacrifice in devotion; which is, already, the literal meaning behind the breaking of the curse ("willing sacrifice").
As Robert Eggers explained in one interview: "Orlok drinks blood from the heart, not the neck. Now obviously you can't pierce a breastbone, so it doesn't really make sense. It makes much more sense to drink someone's blood from their neck. But in folklore, when people are experiencing vampiric attacks it's similar to old hag syndrome [a colloquial term for sleep paralysis] where you have pressure on your chest, so people interpreted it as vampires drinking blood from their chest," he continues. "But there are also folk vampires who didn't drink blood, but just fornicated with their widows until their widows died from it. So I think it's all part of the source material." In an interview to Vulture, Robert Eggers would add: "in addition, for this film, drinking heart blood had physical, poetical appeal." This is connected with Count Orlok being a strigoi from Balkan folklore, the original psychic vampire, and, faithful to his myth, it's not blood specifically he feeds on: he drains their victims living energy, their life force, their souls.
Love and Thomas Hutter
Ellen associates love with Thomas: "From our love, I became as normal"; "Our love was supposed to be sacred"; "Let him see. Let him see our love!"
Victorian society ("Victorianism”) was ruled by a rigid set of social and moral codes: “Cult of Domesticity” or “Victorian morality”, deeply rooted in Christian values and virtues like chastity, modesty and self-discipline, especially for women. The ideal Victorian woman was seen as pure, submissive and devoted to her family, while men were expected to be strong, honorable and protectors/providers of their households. These morals had a deep impact on romantic love. Marriage was the ultimate goal of love. Pre-marital relationships were watched carefully, and any deviation from the moral code (infidelity, unchastity or divorce) was met with severe social consequences. In Victorian society, marriage was a complex social contract, which served multiple purposes: social order, maintaining social status, ensuring financianl stability and upholding family honor.
Victorian love was idealized to be chaste, modest and restrained. Aligned with the "cult of domesticity", Victorian love was also "domesticated", tempered devotion confined to the household. According to Walter Houghton, "Victorian Frame of Mind", married love was a sacrament, meant to exclude animalistic impulses. Unrestrained passion and erotism, was not love, but lust, the author said. True love was familial and domestic, for "passion" was considered the opposite of "love", and corruptive. Victorian love is an alchemy where the wife disappears into her husband’s legal identity, and becomes his property.
While Victorian society was governed by ideals of morality and modesty, there was also a private fascination with the forbidden and the transgressive, evident in the popularity of Gothic novels and the exploration of darker themes such as madness, sexuality, the supernatural and the complexities of love and desire, the tension between individual freedom and social constraints. One of the prime examples being “Wuthering Heights” by Emily Brontë (which is also one of the inspirations for “Nosferatu”) where passion, obsession and tragedy challenge the idealized portrayal of love from earlier literature. Marked by the intense and destructive love between Heathcliff and Catherine, the novel deals with themes of revenge, the destructive power of love and social class.
Amidst the domesticated Victorian love, there was dark, fierce and cannibalistic passion on the side, explored in Gothic novels, illustrating the savagery of the heart, the desire to devour, where love and eating weren’t so different, after all. Torn between prudishness and erotism, repression and explosion, the cozy warmth of the home and the sexuality of the streets, the domestic sphere and freedom and liberation. Nature vs. society. To Robert Eggers, "it was always clear [to me] that Nosferatu is a demon lover story” and "a tale of love and obsession and a Gothic romance".
The “maiden’s token” she sent with Thomas was meant for Orlok, and an invitation for him to haunt her again. Ellen has premonitions (she had a dream just after the prologue); and she knows Thomas will be sent to Orlok. She does this token in front of her symbolic window, and the next scene after this is Herr Knock’s conjuring Orlok.
When Thomas is already in Orlok’s castle in Transylvania, the count notices his “maiden token”, and asks to see it. As he opens it, and smells it, he immediately notices the scent of lilacs on Ellen’s hair. To Orlok, this is a confirmation that Ellen remembers their past life together, because like costume designer Linda Muir tells us, lilacs remind Orlok "from when he was alive” and in connection with Ellen. His passion and desire to merge souls with her is the only humanizing trait he was able to keep in his cursed strigoi self (who stripped him of all his best human qualities).
Orlok keeps the locket for himself, because he knows it’s meant for him, and he'll use it for the Sex Magick divorce ritual, to annul Thomas and Ellen's wedding in the spiritual realm. And this interpretation is also supported by the “Wuthering Heights” inspiration behind this story: after Catherine’s premature death, Heathcliff goes to the chapel to see her coffin. He places a strand of his hair inside of her necklace-locket, for her ghost to haunt him.
The Heart and Count Orlok
While Thomas Hutter is "Victorian love" in Ellen's character arc; her "heart" is associated with Count Orlok. "My heart is lost without my Thomas", she reveals after Anna Harding says her words come from her "honest heart". Not only the silver heart locket (that he will keep into the second act), but her asking Thomas "Kiss my heart. My heart!", and she'll give Orlok, quite literally, her heart (for him to feed on). Both Thomas and Anna Harding (Orlok's victims) will also mention their hearts: "Our friendship is a precious balm to my heart" (Anna); "Your horror has rent our hearts, but you must hear us."
Count Orlok is a strigoi, a cursed creature, but he was once an extremely wealthy man, and this is visible not only in his estate (castle), heritage (nobility; “Lord”) and, also, on his costume design, as a Transylvanian Count from around 1580-1590, as Linda Muir describes in one interview: “the overall look was to establish Orlok as a once-real person with a life, with money, with wealth, with entitlement, with attitude”; "Orlok would have been a young, vital, you know, “I’m a sexy, handsome, gorgeous, rich beyond belief man.”" But, like Robert Eggers revealed in one interview, his Orlok isn't interested in world domination nor spreading his plague, all he wants is Ellen, for her to "be one with [him] ever-eternally", and for her to break the curse, because she's the reincarnation of his wife or lover, and he can't be "sated without" her (which in 16th century English means he can't rest, find peace in death, without her soul by his side).
We see Orlok using his wealth to get Ellen; nor only to travel but, mainly, to trick Thomas Hutter into signing the covenant papers (the divorce papers where he forsakes his marriage to Ellen, and promises her to Orlok) in exchange for a sack of gold. Thomas intuition tells him there’s a hidden motivation at work here, but he ignores it in favor of his ambition. But Thomas’ signature is not the only “exchange” we see happening in this scene: as Orlok gives Thomas a part of his wealth, he takes Ellen’s heart locket. And there’s a difference of monetary value here: he gives Thomas gold, while keeping silver for himself (Ellen's locket), which is considered less valuable.
This is a subversion of the "money" theme from the "Dracula" novel, where Count Dracula's castle is filled with opulent furnishings, hires solicitors, makes deals with banks to expand his empire, and buys several properties around London. Here, Orlok buys a decrepit ruin, which amazes even Thomas himself ("Forgive me, but is it not, well, a ruin?"). And he keeps his sarcophagus at the chapel of Grünewald Manor, beneath the rose window, representing his yearning for higher spiritual realms, and to be free from Nosferatu curse. He doesn't employ his wealth to improve the building, nor anything else. He doesn't care about wealth, he's already dead. Orlok's greatest treasure is not the silver locket for its own sake, it's the scent of lilacs on Ellen's hair, which remind him of his human life, of their past life together, of what they once were. The locket is also heart-shaped, symbolic for Ellen's love and soul.
Friedrich and Anna Harding are the mirror (and opposite) pair to Ellen and Orlok, in "Nosferatu" (2024), and we find several parallels between them throughout the film. Ellen and Anna are opposite characters, like Robert Eggers tells us "unlike her friend Anna (Emma Corrin), Ellen cannot, or will not, conceal her sexual desires".
After the prologue, Ellen is trying to make Thomas return to bed because “the honeymoon was yet too short”, and she urges him to “take off your shoes”, and begs for “one minute more”. Thomas sees this behavior from Ellen as her being a “doting wife” to him, submissive and eager to please him, because women, in the early 19th century, weren’t supposed to have nor display sexual desire, and their sexuality was owned and controlled by their husbands. Thomas is already satisfied, he has to be off to work, and so he leaves. Ellen is clearly displeased by this, but says nothing. Later, at the Harding household Ellen devours Thomas with kisses, a scene which will find parallel in Orlok feeding on Thomas during the Solomonari Sex Magick divorce ritual, foreshadowing of "you could never please me as he could", and of the connection between Ellen and Orlok.
Friedrich Harding resents Ellen, and doesn't want her anywhere near his daughters ("I thought it was agreed you were to keep the girls from her"), and reluctantly accepts the friendship between her and Anna, out of respect for his long-time friend, Thomas, but still worries she might "contaminate" his wife ("you mustn’t be swept up in her fairy ways"), which will culminate in him blaming Ellen for Anna's sickness (contagion).
Friedrich resents Ellen not only due to what she represents ("otherness"; "sickness"; "female sexuality"), but mostly because he recognizes his own nature in her: “rutting goat”; “always hungry”; “her dashing young husband is leaving her bedside cold” as he jokes with Thomas before his departure. And he tells Ellen, himself: “I am most sensitive to your ardent nature”. And Ellen recognizes this resentment, as she'll ask him, herself, as he expells both her and Thomas from his household: "Why do you hate me? You have never liked me. Never." Friedrich resents Ellen because she's a woman, and, as such, she shouldn’t have this nature, while Ellen is envious of him because he gets to display his sexuality freely, while society tells her she has to repress hers.
Ellen has this “hysteric fit” as Friedrich and Anna are displaying sexual desire in public, and almost kissing. The narrative has established that Ellen controls her entire connection with Orlok, and it’s her who summons him for their communications to happen (telepathic, inside of her mind). She channels her sexual energy to conjure him, to call him to her; which is what she’s doing in this scene. She’s covered in slime and muck, representing her affiliation with nature, her desire for freedom (nature vs. society). She’s also convulsing erotically at the shore, in the sea. She’s not only giving Orlok entrance (invitation) into Wisburg by sea, but this also provides the context for her longing for the sea itself, as it symbolizes her yearning for Olrok to come to her, and how he represents nature itself in her character arc. "Destiny!"
Fast forward, Professor Von Franz will be introduced in the plot and began to unravel the truth behind Ellen’s Victorian diagnose. She’s not “melancholic”, she’s a medium who communicates with the spiritual world (“I believe she has always been highly conductive to these cosmic forces, uniquely so”), and her “hysteric fits” are, in fact, trance mediumship (“the pupil is expanded. It does not contract naturally to light. A second sight. She is no longer here. She communes now with another realm.”). Von Franz also says she’s “obsessed” of some “daemon”, (not "possessed"): a daemon is haunting her, and communicating with her, influencing her behavior throught words. However, and since Ellen, like the rest of the Victorian characters, doesn’t understand any of this, she’ll interpret this as if Orlok is a demon possessing her body.
Meanwhile Thomas returns, and the haunting stops: Ellen thinks it's his love, and not her stopping her conjuring of Orlok. However, when Anna Harding points this out, and in connection with her melancholy, Ellen gets upset: "I am only glad that you have become yourself again. It seems a miracle. Perhaps Professor Franz was wrong. Perhaps it was only your wish to see Thomas safely returned, and your... your [my melancholy?]” Ellen wants to be free of her medicalization, and Professor Von Franz has begun to give her answers about her power, but she doesn’t understand, and she wants to.
"Well where is it? Your money? Your promotion? Your house? Where is that which is so precious to you? [...] For what? For what? For these... things?"
Only, later, when she sees Orlok in the flesh for the first time ever, and he’s monstruous, she thinks this is confirmation that he’s, indeed, a demon, and he has been possessing her, compelling her to have these “hysterical fits” and creating this sexual attraction to him. Only in her "possession scene" will Ellen realize this is not the case: her trance mediumship allows her to communicate with the spiritual world as a whole; Orlok isn't "a demon possessing her body", it's all on herself, and it’s her who has been summoning Orlok this entire time, which is why she says she'll become a demon without Thomas (without her husband owning and controlling her sexuality) and "I'm unclean!".
"I’ll kill him! He shall never harm you again. Never!"
Only, Ellen has just realized it’s not Orlok, it’s her own power, her own nature. And she also realized something else: Thomas won’t ever accept her power and will always call the doctors to deal with her (“I shall send for Doctor Sievers” and “Ellen, wake from this. I love you! I love you.”).He now believes it's Orlok who's making his wife "sick", and once he's destroyed everything will be back to "normal", and she'll be the perfect Victorian wife to him, then. His (Victorian) love and her medicalization are one of the same: Thomas is society, and he wants to keep her in the domestic sphere. And this “unclean” nature finds a parallel in Friedrich Harding, where Robert Eggers makes another subversion of the “Dracula” novel, based on 1980’s Feminist literary criticism of Victorian authors who created female heroines who have sexual desire and sexual energy, and need to be killed and punished for that. Here it’s Friedrich Harding, the Victorian patriarch, the “rutting goat”, who gets punished with death by the narrative, alongside his God-fearing wife and children (Victorian family ideal).
After the funerals, there’s a notorious difference between Thomas and Friedrich Harding. Thomas is driven by revenge against Orlok, not only because of what he thinks he did to Ellen, but because he believes everything that has happened it's his own fault, since he thinks he was the one who unleashed Orlok into the world (nevermind what Ellen told him the night before: "I have brought this evil upon us [...] I called out..."), as he asks for both Ellen and Friedrich's forgiveness: "Please, it is my fault! Forgive me my dear, sweet friend!"
Friedrich Harding, on the other hand, doesn’t care about revenge. He’s already dying from the “blood plague”, and he blames himself because of what happened to his wife and children, and could use his last strength to destroy Orlok to avenge his wife and children's killings, like Thomas, alongside Dr. Sievers and Professor Von Franz. "Please, forgive me, all of you. My reason could not accept..." However, plans to destroy monsters have no interest to him, and he goes to his wife and daughters mausoleum to die alongside them, instead. Friedrich lost his greatest treasures; his wealth and social reputation don’t matter to him anymore. He’s already dead.
"I shall never sleep again. Never."
Anna Harding’s burial costume is very reminiscence of a wedding dress. It’s not confirmed if this is the case with Anna’s character, but many women were buried in their wedding dresses in the 19th century, because it was tradition for the dead to be dressed in their best clothes, and, for many women, their wedding dress was their finest fashion possession. Anna’s character is a wealthy woman with many fashion choices at her disposal to illustrate her wealth. However, a huge part of her character is being precious to Friedrich Harding, so this angle would fit her story. Queen Victoria herself was buried in her wedding attire, in spite of being queen of an empire.
And this finds parallel in Ellen scene with Orlok, as she accepts his covenant ("be one with me ever-eternally"), and wears her wedding dress filled with lilacs: in her hair, in her veil, in the dress itself, the symbolic lilacs which connect both Ellen and Orlok, showcasing this is what Ellen desired all along. This is her destiny. She accepts him after being confronted with the threat of his destruction by the men plotting to drive a spike of cold iron throught him. She doesn't know about the instructions of the Solomonari codex of secrets, Professor Von Franz never told her nor anyone about them; but they are confirmed to have been successful at the end, and the curse of Nosferatu was broken, and Orlok soul was set free, united with Ellen's, forever (strigoi myth).
At the end, like Friedrich Harding with Anna; Ellen could not resist Orlok. She's already dead, and so, like Friedrich goes to Anna, she summons Orlok to come to her. All Ellen ever wanted was to be someone’s greatest treasure, and she is, to Orlok; all he wants is her soul alongside his, forever. That's his whole motivation in this story. Like Friedrich himself, Orlok was wealthy beyond belief when he was alive, but none of that matters in death; Ellen’s soul is the most precious thing to him. Their souls were separated by death, and are united by death. But while the plague has taken both Friedrich and Anna, Ellen and Orlok union ends the plague of Nosferatu, by breaking the curse. To fulfill their covenant, Ellen has to die, and Orlok needs to have his soul set free from the rotten corpse it's trapped in (Nosferatu); hence why she doesn't need to be told about any instructions from any ancient manuscript. They are already implied to make their spirits one. From his part, Orlok is very much aware of these instructions because he wrote them, himself.
Love and heart become one in this scene; as Ellen offers both her heart (willing sacrifice) and her love (covenant) to Orlok. And he will drink her blood/soul and trap it inside of Nosferatu, alongside his, where they will merge together. At dawn, when Nosferatu is destroyed, both Ellen and Orlok’s united souls are liberated to the Afterlife, as their joined blood pours out of it. But Orlok is not merely drinking her blood and getting her soul in this scene, he's also having sex with her, as the breaking of the curse says: "with him lay in close embrace until first cock crow". And this will find parallel in a earlier scene between Friedrich and Anna Harding:
Friedrich Harding will go on to defile Anna’s corpse, as he’s found on top of her. This is a more direct parallel with Ellen and Orlok being found at the end, by the same characters (Thomas, Dr. Sievers and Professor Von Franz), where the corpse can consent to the act. But while Friedrich and Anna are inside of a mausoleum and in the dark (society); Ellen and Orlok at in the light, being bathed by sunlight, and Professor Von Franz will place their symbolic lilacs around their bodies (nature).
Friedrich and Anna Harding represent the true horror of women’s oppression in Victory society. Women were property of their husbands, with no agency whatesover, her bodies and sexuality owned by their husbands, fully dominated by them (even in death), who could physically and sexually assault them with no fear of repercussions, and infected them with "blood plagues" (especially syphilis) quite often. God-fearing, Christian values, morality, decency and concern with social reputation all fall apart in this scene, as Victorian society hypocrisy is brought to light by Professor Von Franz, the occult scholar.
Ellen and Orlok's union is blessed by nature; the great Pagan priestess and the Pagan priest-shaman follower of Zalmoxis, both demonized by Christian Victorian society, together and their sexuality on full display, no longer shameful nor demonic. Ellen is naked; fully embracing herself, fully liberated from Victorian society. Ellen and Orlok are the owners of the secrets of immortality; death, resurrection, rebirth and reincarnation. Their spiritual and sexual union (Sex Magick) has healed them and the world, and the plague was lifted.
Friedrich and Anna are in dark (ignorance); while Ellen and Orlok are in light (knowledge). Both men “can’t resist” these female characters; but while Friedrich used Anna’s corpse for his own sexual pleasure; Orlok gave Ellen pure ecstasy (orgasm), their scene is about her sexual pleasure, not his. Friedrich and Anna are riddled with plague; while Ellen and Orlok are fully healed; Ellen healed Orlok from Nosferatu curse (“his affliction”), and Orlok was the only one who could heal Ellen “sanguine temperament” by draining her blood (“hysteria”). They healed each other, and by consequence, they ended the plague for everyone else.
As for Thomas, he never stood a chance, for he and Ellen were completely mismatched for each other, they wanted different things: while Ellen wanted to break free from social convention, Thomas wanted to embraced it, while Ellen wanted to be in nature, Thomas wanted to keep her in the domestic sphere. He goes from wanting wealth to seek revenge, and ends losing Ellen in the process. However, he already lost before she was dead. He lost Ellen when he accepted to travel to Transylvania, they both just didn't realize it until later. As for that “last look of love”; to whom was it, truly? Ellen and Orlok’s souls were already united, and ready to ascend, as their joined blood/souls are pouring out of Nosferatu. Was this “last look of love” to Thomas or to Orlok?
Comments
Post a Comment